Skip to content

Trump's imposed tariffs declared unlawful by a U.S. court, with a temporary stay in effect

The US Court of Appeals has mainly affirmed a decision by a specialized federal trade court, determining that the US president lacked the legal authority to declare a national emergency and impose tariffs on nearly every foreign country.

Trump's imposed tariffs are deemed unlawful by the American court, yet they remain operational...
Trump's imposed tariffs are deemed unlawful by the American court, yet they remain operational temporarily.

Trump's imposed tariffs declared unlawful by a U.S. court, with a temporary stay in effect

The U.S. Court of International Trade and a U.S. appeals court have ruled that most of the tariffs imposed by President Trump under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) exceeded his authority and are illegal. The tariffs, which targeted imports from China, Canada, and Mexico, must be lifted, while tariffs based on other laws like Section 232 on steel, aluminum, and automobiles remain in effect. The Trump administration has appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn these rulings.

The court's decision could limit the speed and severity with which Trump could act regarding tariffs. The ruling upheld a decision by a specialised federal trade court, mostly. However, a portion of the previous ruling that would have immediately cancelled the tariffs was struck down.

The potential refund of tariff revenue, estimated to be significant, could deliver a financial blow to the U.S. Treasury. By July, the U.S. Treasury had collected $142bn in tariff revenue, more than double at the same point the previous year. The Justice Department has expressed concern about the financial implications of revoking Trump's tariffs, warning that it could mean "financial ruin" for the U.S.

Trump has expressed opposition to the removal of the tariffs, stating on Truth Social that the tariffs are still in effect and that their removal would be a "total disaster" for the country. The Justice Department's warning suggests that the removal of the tariffs could have significant financial consequences for the U.S., potentially impacting the financial stability of the nation.

The tariffs have increased fears of higher prices and slower economic growth. Trump's tariffs have also alienated U.S. trading partners and allies. The court's ruling could be a serious blow to the administration's coercive trade diplomacy model, which used tariffs to pressure the European Union, Japan, and other countries into accepting one-sided trade deals.

As the case proceeds to the U.S. Supreme Court, it remains to be seen whether the tariffs will be upheld or revoked, and what the financial implications will be for the U.S. government and economy.

Read also:

Latest